10 C.F.R. Subpart D—Dispute Resolution Process
Title 10 - Energy
The parties, i.e., the sponsor and the Department, shall include provisions in the Standby Support Contract that specify the procedures set forth in this subpart for the resolution of disputes under a Standby Support Contract. §§950.31 and 950.32 address disputes involving covered events; §§950.33 and 950.34 address disputes involving covered costs; and §§950.36 and 950.37 address disputes involving other contract matters. (a) If a sponsor disagrees with the Covered Event Determination rendered in accordance with §950.22 and cannot resolve the dispute informally with the Claims Administrator, then the disagreement is subject to resolution as follows: (1) A sponsor shall, within thirty (30) days of receipt of the Covered Event Determination, deliver to the Claims Administrator written notice of a sponsor's rebuttal which sets forth reasons for its disagreement, including any expert opinion obtained by the sponsor. (2) After submission of the sponsor's rebuttal to the Claims Administrator, the parties shall have fifteen (15) days during which time they must informally and in good faith participate in mediation to attempt to resolve the disagreement before instituting the process under paragraph (b) of this section. If the parties reach agreement through mediation, the agreement shall constitute a Final Determination on Covered Events. (3) The parties shall jointly select the neutral(s). The parties shall share equally the cost of the mediation. (b) If the parties cannot resolve the disagreement through mediation under the timeframe established under paragraph (a)(2) of this section and the sponsor elects to continue pursuing the claim, the sponsor shall within ten (10) days submit any remaining issues in controversy to the Department of Energy Board of Contract Appeals (Board) or its successor, for binding resolution by an Administrative Judge of the Board utilizing the Board's Summary Trial with Binding Decision process. The parties shall abide by the procedures of the Board for Summary Trial with Binding Decision. The parties agree that the decision of the Board constitutes a Final Determination on Covered Events. (a) If the parties reach a Final Determination on Covered Events through mediation, or Summary Trial with Binding Decision as set forth in this subpart, the Final Determination on Covered Events is a final settlement of the issue, made by the sponsor and the Program Administrator. The sponsor, and the Department, may rely on, and neither may challenge, the Final Determination on Covered Events in any future Certification of Covered Costs related to the covered event that was the subject of that Initial Determination. (b) The parties agree that no appeal shall be taken or further review sought, and that the Final Determination on Covered Events is final, conclusive, non-appealable and may not be set aside, except for fraud. (a) If a sponsor disagrees with the Claim Determination rendered in accordance with §950.24 and cannot resolve the dispute informally with the Claims Administrator, then the parties agree that any dispute must be resolved as follows: (1) A sponsor shall, within thirty (30) days of receipt of the Claim Determination, deliver to the Claims Administrator in writing notice of and reasons for its disagreement (Sponsor's Rebuttal), including any expert opinion obtained by the sponsor. (2) After submission of the sponsor's rebuttal to the Claims Administrator, the parties have fifteen (15) days to informally and in good faith participate in mediation to resolve the disagreement before instituting the process under paragraph (b) of this section. If the parties reach agreement through mediation, the agreement shall constitute a Final Claim Determination. (3) The parties shall jointly select the mediator(s). The parties shall share equally the cost of the mediator(s). (b) If the parties cannot resolve the disagreement through mediation under the timeframe established under paragraph (a)(2) of this section, any remaining issues in controversy shall be submitted by the sponsor within ten (10) days to the Department of Energy Board of Contract Appeals (Board) or its successor, for binding arbitration by an Administrative Judge of the Board utilizing the Board's Summary Trial with Binding Decision process. The parties shall abide by the procedures of the Board for Summary Trial with Binding Decision. The parties agree that the decision of the Board shall constitute a Final Claim Determination. (a) If the parties reach a Final Claim Determination through mediation, or Summary Trial with Binding Decision as set forth in this subpart, the Final Claim Determination is a final settlement of the issue, made by the sponsor and the Program Administrator. (b) The parties agree that no appeal shall be taken or further review sought and that the Final Claim Determination is final, conclusive, non-appealable, and may not be set aside, except for fraud. Once a Final Claim Determination is reached by the methods set forth in this subpart, the parties intend that such a Final Claim Determination shall constitute a final settlement of the claim and the sponsor may immediately present to the Department a Final Claim Determination for payment. (a) If the parties disagree over terms or conditions of the Standby Support Contract other than disagreements related to covered events or covered costs, then the parties shall engage in informal dispute resolution as follows: (1) The parties shall engage in good faith efforts to resolve the dispute after written notification by one party to the other that there is a contract matter in dispute. (2) If the parties cannot reach a resolution of the matter in disagreement within thirty (30) days of the written notification of the matter in dispute, then the parties shall have fifteen (15) days during which time they must informally and in good faith participate in mediation to attempt to resolve the disagreement before instituting the process under paragraph (b) of this section. If the parties reach agreement through mediation, the agreement shall constitute a Final Agreement on the matter in dispute. (3) The parties shall jointly select the neutral(s). The parties shall share equally the cost of the mediation. (b) If the parties cannot resolve the disagreement through mediation under the timeframe established in paragraph (a)(2) of this section and either party elects to continue pursuing the disagreement, that party shall within ten (10) days submit any remaining issues in controversy to the Department of Energy Board of Contract Appeals (Board) or its successor, for binding resolution by an Administrative Judge of the Board utilizing the Board's Summary Trial with Binding Decision process. The parties shall abide by the procedures of the Board for Summary Trial with Binding Decision. The parties shall agree that the decision of the Board constitutes a Final Decision on the matter in dispute. (a) If the parties reach a Final Agreement on a contract matter in dispute through mediation, or a Final Decision on a contract matter in dispute through a Summary Trial with Binding Decision as set forth in this subpart, the Final Agreement or Final Decision is a final settlement of the contract matter in dispute, made by the sponsor and the Program Administrator. (b) The parties agree that no appeal shall be taken or further review sought, and that the Final Agreement or Final Decision is final, conclusive, non-appealable and may not be set aside, except for fraud.
Title 10: Energy
PART 950—STANDBY SUPPORT FOR CERTAIN NUCLEAR PLANT DELAYS
Subpart D—Dispute Resolution Process
§ 950.30 General.
§ 950.31 Covered event dispute resolution.
§ 950.32 Final Determination on covered events.
§ 950.33 Covered costs dispute resolution.
§ 950.34 Final claim determination.
§ 950.35 Payment of final claim determination.
§ 950.36 Other contract matters in dispute.
§ 950.37 Final agreement or final decision.
