15 C.F.R. Subpart C—Investigations
Title 15 - Commerce and Foreign Trade
Source: 68 FR 66704, Nov. 28, 2003, unless otherwise noted.
(a) Preliminary reconnaissance. (1) An initial assessment of the event, including an initial site reconnaissance, if deemed appropriate by the Director, will be conducted. This assessment will be done within a few hours of the event, if possible. The Director may establish and deploy a Team to conduct the preliminary reconnaissance, using the criteria established in §270.102 of this part, or may have information gathered at the site of a building failure without establishing a Team. (2) If the Director establishes and deploys a Team to conduct the preliminary reconnaissance, the Team shall perform all duties pursuant to section 2(b)(2) of the Act, and may perform all activities that Teams are authorized to perform under the Act and these procedures, with a focus on gathering and preserving evidence, inspecting the site of the building failure, and interviewing of eyewitnesses, survivors, and first responders. Collections of evidence by a Team established for preliminary reconnaissance are investigatory in nature and will not be considered research for any purpose. At the completion of the preliminary reconnaissance, the Team will report its findings to the Director in a timely manner. The Director may either determine that the Team should conduct further investigation, or may direct the Team to immediately prepare the public report as required by section 8 of the Act. (3) If the preliminary reconnaissance is conducted without the establishment of a Team, the leader of the initial assessment will report his/her findings to the Director in a timely manner. The Director will decide whether to establish a team and conduct an investigation using the criteria established in §270.102 of this part. (b) Investigation plan. (1) If the Director establishes a Team without ordering preliminary reconnaissance, establishes a Team after preliminary reconnaissance, or establishes a Team to conduct preliminary reconnaissance and subsequently determines that further investigation is necessary prior to preparing the public report required by section 8 of the Act, the Director, or his/her designee, will formulate a plan that includes: (i) A brief description of the building failure; (ii) The criteria upon which the decision to conduct the investigation was based; (iii) Supporting effort(s) by other organizations either in place or expected in the future; (iv) Identification of the Lead Investigator and Team members; (v) The technical investigation plan; (vi) Site, community, and local, state, and Federal agency liaison status; and (vii) Estimated duration and cost. (2) To the extent practicable, the Director will include the most appropriate expertise on each Team from within NIST, other government agencies, and the private sector. The NCST Advisory Committee may be convened as soon as feasible following the launch of an investigation to provide the Director the benefit of its advice on investigation Team activities. (c) Investigation. (1) The duration of an investigation that proceeds beyond preliminary reconnaissance will be as little as a few months to as long as a few years depending on the complexity of the event. (2) Tasks that may be completed during investigations that proceed beyond preliminary reconnaissance include: (i) Consult with experts in building design and construction, fire protection engineering, emergency evacuation, and members of other investigation teams involved in the event to identify technical issues and major hypotheses requiring investigation. (ii) Collect data from the building(s) owner and occupants, local authorities, and contractors and suppliers. Such data will include relevant building and fire protection documents, records, video and photographic data, field data, and data from interviews and other oral and written accounts from building occupants, emergency responders, and other witnesses. (iii) Collect and analyze physical evidence, including material samples and other forensic evidence, to the extent they are available. (iv) Determine the conditions in the building(s) prior to the event, which may include the materials of construction and contents; the location, size, and condition of all openings that may have affected egress, entry, and fire conditions (if applicable); the installed security and/or fire protection systems (if applicable); the number of occupants and their approximate locations at the time of the event. (v) Reconstruct the event within the building(s) using computer models to identify the most probable technical cause (or causes) of the failure and the uncertainty(ies) associated with it (them). Such models may include initial damage, blast effects, pre-existing deficiencies and phenomena such as fire spread, smoke movement, tenability, occupant behavior and response, evacuation issues, cooperation of security and fire protection systems, and building collapse. (vi) Conduct small and full-scale experiments to provide additional data and verify the computer models being used. (vii) Examine the impact of alternate building/system/equipment design and use on the survivability of the building and its occupants. (viii) Analyze emergency evacuation and occupant responses to better understand the actions of the first responders and the impediments to safe egress encountered by the occupants. (ix) Analyze the relevant building practices, including code adoption and enforcement practices, to determine the extent to which the circumstances that led to this building failure have regional or national implications. (x) Identify specific areas in building and fire codes, standards, and building practices that may warrant revisions based on investigation findings. (xi) Identify research and other appropriate actions required to help prevent future building failures. (d) If a disaster site contains multiple building failures, the Director will narrow the scope of the investigation plan taking into account available financial and personnel resources, and giving priority to failures offering the most opportunity to advance the safety of building codes. The Director may consider the capabilities of NIST in establishing priorities. [68 FR 66704, Nov. 28, 2003, as amended at 69 FR 33571, June 16, 2004] (a) General. Except as provided in this section, a Team investigation will have priority over any other investigation of any other Federal agency. (b) Criminal acts. (1) If the Attorney General, in consultation with the Director, determines, and notifies the Director that circumstances reasonably indicate that the building failure being investigated by a Team may have been caused by a criminal act, the Team will relinquish investigative priority to the appropriate law enforcement agency. (2) If a criminal investigation of the building failure being investigated by a Team is initiated at the state or local level, the Team will relinquish investigative priority to the appropriate law enforcement agency. (3) The relinquishment of investigative priority by the Team will not otherwise affect the authority of the Team to continue its investigation under the Act. (c) National Transportation Safety Board. If the National Transportation Safety Board is conducting an investigation related to an investigation of a Team, the National Transportation Safety Board investigation will have priority over the Team investigation. Such priority will not otherwise affect the authority of the Team to continue its investigation under the Act. (d) Although NIST will share any evidence of criminal activity that it obtains in the course of an investigation under the Act with the appropriate law enforcement agency, NIST will not participate in the investigation of any potential criminal activity. NIST will coordinate its investigation with any search and rescue or search and recovery efforts being undertaken at the site of the building failure, including FEMA urban search and rescue teams, local emergency management agencies, and local emergency response groups. Upon arrival at a disaster site, the Lead Investigator will identify the lead of the search and rescue operations and will work closely with that person to ensure coordination of efforts. [68 FR 66704, Nov. 28, 2003, as amended at 69 FR 33571, June 16, 2004] NIST will enter into Memoranda of Understanding with Federal, State, and local entities, as appropriate, to ensure the coordination of investigations. The Director will determine the appropriate resources that a Team will require to carry out its investigation and will ensure that those resources are available to the Team. (a) Not later than 90 days after completing an investigation, a Team shall issue a public report which includes: (1) An analysis of the likely technical cause or causes of the building failure investigated; (2) Any technical recommendations for changes to or the establishment of evacuation or emergency response procedures; (3) Any recommended specific improvements to building standards, codes, and practices; and (4) Recommendations for research and other appropriate actions needed to help prevent future building failures. (b) A Team that is directed to prepare its public report immediately after conducting a preliminary reconnaissance will issue a public report not later than 90 days after completion of the preliminary reconnaissance. The public report will be in accordance with paragraph (a) of this section, but will be summary in nature. (c) A Team that continues to conduct an investigation after conducting a preliminary reconnaissance will issue a public report not later than 90 days after completing the investigation in accordance with paragraph (a) of this section. (a) NIST will establish methods to provide updates to the public on its planning and progress of an investigation. Methods may include: (1) A public Web site; (2) Mailing lists, to include an emphasis on e-mail; (3) Semi-annual written progress reports; (4) Media briefings; and (5) Public meetings. (b) Requests for information on the plans and conduct of an investigation should be submitted to the NIST Public and Business Affairs Division.
Title 15: Commerce and Foreign Trade
PART 270—NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION SAFETY TEAMS
Subpart C—Investigations
§ 270.200 Technical conduct of investigation.
§ 270.201 Priority of investigation.
§ 270.202 Coordination with search and rescue efforts.
§ 270.203 Coordination with Federal, State, and local entities.
§ 270.204 Provision of additional resources and services needed by a team.
§ 270.205 Reports.
§ 270.206 Public briefings and requests for information.
